And the makers came up with very imaginative ways to make characters
and objects move. People could snake through the crowd if they're skinny,
or beat like a drum if they're fat. Furniture could come to life and dance
with the people without disrupting the rhythm one bit. That hatrack and
chair sure had some great moves.
For variety they even threw in a couple of plot points. Dippy Dawg and
Clarabelle Cow exchanged pranks in a hilarious face-off where they showed
personality. Then suddenly near the end a paddy wagon of cops showed up
to spoil the fun, but I LOL'ed at what really happened. I was never bored
at any moment.
As we’ve seen, Mickey started off his career with a couple of friends in addition to Minnie and Pluto – Clarabelle Cow and Horace Horsecollar. In this short, he adds Goofy to the mix. And, for the first time, Goofy mixes things up with Clarabelle, Horace and Minnie. Pluto’s absent in this one, but it’s all good, as Goofy shows his comedic chops.
The subject of the short is really just one big party. Mickey and Minnie are the hosts, but a plethora of animals have joined the fun, with a huge dance floor full of eager dancers. Minnie provides the music at the piano for the majority of the short, while Mickey opens up with Horace and Goofy in the kitchen making food. Goofy gets the honor of unveiling the food to the masses, causing the predictable stampede to get snacks.
This is another Mickey short that has a rhythm and flow to it, with every action taking place to a steady beat. The music picks things up, as there’s really not a lot of story here, but having the characters swing along to the rhythm keeps things swinging. Even inanimate objects get into the act, such as a pair of lamps flipping on and off in time with the music.
Ultimately, the cops show up to break up the party, but instead decide to join in the fun. The final scenes of the short feature Minnie and Mickey dancing up a storm surrounded by the policemen. It makes for a cute and emotionally satisfying ending.
There are some issues with the short, however. For one thing, Minnie doesn’t have much of a role. She spends the majority of the cartoon seated at a piano, and with the exception of an animated stool giving her trouble, there’s not a great gag associated with her. In fact, most of the characters in this short get upstaged by Goofy.
In addition to his role in preparing the snacks and unveiling them, Goofy gets another great gag when he takes a party noisemaker and uses it to goose Clarabelle. The interaction between the two of them is very well done and very funny. It makes me smile thinking of how they would interact in
The Three Musketeers, the direct to video film with Mickey, Donald and Goofy that came out a few years back. That film seemed like a throwback at the time, and it’s nice to see that there was a basis for the Goofy-Clarabelle relationship in that movie.
And of course, the story in this one is pretty weak. There’s no real conflict or struggle for Mickey to overcome, so you’re left with a short, fun but fluffy piece of work. And that’s just fine for one short, but it’s not sustainable for multiple shorts. That’s why you’ve seen more of the Mickeys feature fun stories with conflicts as we move on through the years.
This one was picked to be part of a 'House of Mouse' episode dedicated to the black and white era. It's easy to see why what with all the mad cap rubber-hose action and 30's design and music. There's a quality vintage charm to this one - just check out the decorations at the party, the police uniforms and, best of all, the cars and horse and carts outside.
One question I have about this short is what is the song Mickey and co sing at the beginning that goes: "We're the kitchen mechanics! We control the refreshments!"? I'm not sure if it's unique to this short or if it's a song that already existed.
The Clarabelle and Goofy antagonism was picked up right away in the comics, with her calling him "the half-wittedest dumb ninny I ever knowed!" I liked the line so much that I put it into Gemstone's comics adaptation of
The Three Musketeers film, bringing things full circle!
Click on thumbnail for full size image
Submitted by eutychus