Interesting you point that out. I'm sure the directors didn't care or see them as separate characters, but documentation exists from 1938 indicating Egghead and Elmer (he officially gained the Fudd when Bryan began voicing him) were indeed different characters. Elmer was probably Avery's way or quickly rebranding the Egghead character, although I don't really see it myself.
Originally Posted by: S. C. MacPeter
You're forgetting "A Feud There Was".
I think of Egghead and "Egghead's brother" as different characters. Egghead always has wide-open eyes, usually has a full head of black hair in a "bowl" haircut (except in his debut cartoon "Egghead Rides Again"), and is featured prominently in the cartoons he's in like "Daffy Duck and Egghead" and "Count Me Out". "Egghead's brother" always has squinty eyes, is always bald, and pops in and out throughout the cartoons he's in like "A Feud There Was" and "The Isle of Pingo Pongo". ("Now, Boss?") "Egghead's brother" may have evolved into Elmer Fudd, but he's also kind of like a predecessor of the early Droopy. (Compare "Little Red Walking Hood" and "Wild and Woolfy".)
That said, I can't say the same for proto-Bugs and the fully formed Bugs, who was never called Happy Rabbit. By spring 1939, he was Bugs Bunny, the named he is called in the copyright submissions for both HARE EM SCARE EM and ELMER'S CANDID CAMERA.
S. C. MacPeter35920 wrote:
I think "Happy Rabbit" came from an interview with Mel Blanc. He said something like (probably not an exact quote): "They were going to call him the Happy Rabbit and have him say "Hey, what's cookin'?"." Mel Blanc said that he suggested calling the character Bugs Bunny, after Bugs Hardaway. (But Tex did NOT like the name Bugs Bunny. He wanted to call the character Jack Rabbit.)
And I think of the Hardaway/Dalton rabbit and Bugs Bunny as different characters, even though the Hardaway/Dalton rabbit fakes dying and says "Of course you know this means war!" in "Porky's Hare Hunt", and dresses in drag in "Hare-Um Scare-Um".
Sogturtle wrote a great (fictional) story in which the Hardaway/Dalton rabbit and Bugs Bunny are two different characters. After being "replaced" by Bugs Bunny, the Hardaway/Dalton rabbit followed Ben Hardaway to the Lantz studio and became their new star Woody Woodpecker by wearing a costume. (Woody's changes in appearance over the years were explained by the costume wearing out and the replacement costume not being exactly the same.) When the Lantz studio temporarily closed in the late 1940's, the Hardaway/Dalton rabbit worked with Tex at MGM, playing the rabbit in "Doggone Tired" by wearing a (different) rabbit costume over the Woody Woodpecker costume. ("Bugs was proud of me!")
Sogturtle's story also said that Daffy's crazy behavior in his early years was because he was drunk. If Daffy was sober, he was mean. Thus Daffy started drinking less over the years, and was completely sober by the 1960's. And Porky's small amount of screentime in certain cartoons was because he slipped in a puddle of Daffy's vomit and broke a limb. This story may be buried somewhere in the GAC Forums archives.