The first batch went onto Disney+ today and I spent my evening after dinner watching through them. These were all game changers compared to the terribly quality of the HD transfers done on roughly 100-150 titles a decade ago. They have grain, accurate color, and no modern corrections. Some thoughts on all the shorts presented.
AQUAMANIA: Nicely designed, funny, but highly economical in the Wolfgang tradition. I don't have much to say on its presentation, honestly
BATH DAY: Okay, not as comedic as other studio's shorts but it entertains. The Figaros were on the recent Disney Shorts blu ray and looked better than the rest of the batch, same copy and looking splendid
BUILDING A BUILDING: May of been done from a preservation element as it was noticeably grainier than the other shorts. Still looked very good, puts the HD transfer of STEAMBOAT WILLIE to shame. Has 70s reissue titles, which is whats on the master elements. I didn't mind this, though I am seeing people say they'd rather a recreation, which I understand.
See Erik's upload of the titles here FIGARO AND FRANKIE: Tries to be like Tom and Jerry more than the other Figaro but is very uneven. I didn't even remember Frankie disturbed Figaro's cat nap by short's end. I would've substituted this for a Silly Symphony or a Donald, but that's me. Also looks really good
GOOFY GYMNASTICS: Beyond being very funny, it also looks remarkable. Lots of cel shadows which were usually suppressed in the HD transfers of Disney shorts a decade ago, amazing to see them leave it in. Soundtrack clear as day
THE SKELETON DANCE: Stunning to the point of mouth dropping. The most recommended watch of the batch. Being recorded with the poor Cinephone system, the sound team also gets my respect for doing a great job getting it up to date, given what they likely were up against. Crop also looks better than usual
In conclusion, go seek these out if you can. I'll get photos on here another time. Looking very much forward to future batches if they maintain the high standard set here. I hope future BD releases will only use the transfer presented here and that the shorts that have looked botched in HD for a decade now may be redone. Let's see what the future holds