RareSox
2021-11-11T14:55:06Z
This is going to come across as somewhat of a vent but, Toon in with Me isn't exactly the same for me. Granted, stereotyping is wrong and it still is today, but I specifically remembered that Bill specifically stated during October 19th's episode, after airing Hare Ribbin, and I quote, "Just to remind you that cartoons during the 1940s and 1950s were originally targeted at an adult audience, and were shown before an theatrical film, alongside other shorts and newsreels."

I bring this up because a few shorts that first aired on Toon in with Me or Saturday Morning Cartoons that once aired unedited, started airing edited, but I think it's only the Indian/Chinese stereotyping. Blackface, I can understand, but these cartoons with those Chinese stereotypes aired uncut before. I'm beginning to wonder if I'm out of touch, or the censors were very stubborn with stereotyping this week.

It kinda boggles with my head a bit, but that's just my opinion.
MTGM
  • MTGM
  • Advanced Member
2021-11-12T00:17:24Z
To give what RareSox said some more context, Bad Luck Blackie, Car of Tomorrow, and Bugs' Bonnets all aired on Toon In with Me this week edited despite airing unedited (or in the case of Car of Tomorrow, with one less edit) in the past. They removed the Chinese gag from Bad Luck Blackie even though that cartoon has aired on the network probably 4 times prior to this week and has been unaltered each time, the Native American car gag was removed from Car of Tomorrow despite being retained during a Saturday Morning Cartoons airing months ago (Chinese car gag was still gone), and Bugs' Bonnets had a very obvious (and somewhat hilarious) edit. During the pilgrim and Indian gag between Elmer and Bugs, the screen zooms in on Elmer's face and the audio gets muted for a few seconds before it returns to normal during the next scene. This cartoon was unaltered when it first aired back in May.
UserPostedImageUserPostedImage

I assume all of these inconsistencies with what's allowed mainly depend on who's overseeing what and on which day. I'm not defending the stereotypes themselves, I'm just expressing confusion mainly because MeTV airs a lot of programs with similar material in them (primarily those Westerns), and yet the cartoons are constantly being examined with an ultra-observant eye and having scenes edited during reruns despite being untouched whenever they first appeared on the network. This same mentality is likely why the Tom and Jerry cartoons with the maid character, the earlier Speedy Gonzales cartoons, and "The Prowler" episode of the Flintstones seem to be put off limits despite not being that bad overall.
S. C. MacPeter
2021-11-12T05:04:43Z
Well this is a family show, not something like ToonHeads. It appears originally MeTV wasn't checking what was already censored in the copies Warner gave them (I think they mostly began checking after they aired I Tawt a Puddy Kat uncensored) which is why things have shown up censored and uncensored. Except for the gag in Little Quacker, we have these copies uncut elsewhere and quite honestly, I am fine with these edits if it means more people will watch, be happy, and be interested. Still doesn't excuse them in some cases of showing cartoons with the maid, later ones like "Framed Cat", "Puss Button Kitty", and particularly "Saturday Evening Puss" should be perfectly fine for air, and the latter has been used in promos, so they have it!
RareSox
2021-11-12T13:07:41Z
You fellas do make a valid point. If they wanted to air Saturday Evening Puss, the only thing I would see them cutting out is Mammy's face with her running up across the road from the Frontline. Everything else semes fine as it is.

After all, we do keep getting glimpses of clips from Saturday Evening Puss and even Dog Trouble airing in clip form during the start of The Tom and Jerry Show block on Saturday Morning Cartoons.

I guess it's the inconsistencies that MeTV is going through.

We'll just have to see how The Little Orphan is treated tomorrow, although the blackface gag is likely a red flag that MeTV will likely cut. I'll be around to see it before I get a haircut tomorrow, so we'll just see how that rolls out.
raginggoodfella
2021-11-13T13:29:15Z
Originally Posted by: RareSox 

You fellas do make a valid point. If they wanted to air Saturday Evening Puss, the only thing I would see them cutting out is Mammy's face with her running up across the road from the Frontline. Everything else semes fine as it is.

After all, we do keep getting glimpses of clips from Saturday Evening Puss and even Dog Trouble airing in clip form during the start of The Tom and Jerry Show block on Saturday Morning Cartoons.

I guess it's the inconsistencies that MeTV is going through.

We'll just have to see how The Little Orphan is treated tomorrow, although the blackface gag is likely a red flag that MeTV will likely cut. I'll be around to see it before I get a haircut tomorrow, so we'll just see how that rolls out.



MeTV could show “Saturday Evening Puss” version with the white teenage girl replacing Mammy instead of doing their own editing.
RareSox
2021-11-14T13:54:03Z
Originally Posted by: raginggoodfella 

Originally Posted by: RareSox 

You fellas do make a valid point. If they wanted to air Saturday Evening Puss, the only thing I would see them cutting out is Mammy's face with her running up across the road from the Frontline. Everything else semes fine as it is.

After all, we do keep getting glimpses of clips from Saturday Evening Puss and even Dog Trouble airing in clip form during the start of The Tom and Jerry Show block on Saturday Morning Cartoons.

I guess it's the inconsistencies that MeTV is going through.

We'll just have to see how The Little Orphan is treated tomorrow, although the blackface gag is likely a red flag that MeTV will likely cut. I'll be around to see it before I get a haircut tomorrow, so we'll just see how that rolls out.



MeTV could show “Saturday Evening Puss” version with the white teenage girl replacing Mammy instead of doing their own editing.



To be honest, all they really need to do is just use the redub from the 2000s. They've shown the restored version during the opening scene to The Tom and Jerry show on MeTV. Although the redubbed soundtrack sounds more likely than what you said. I'll keep it in mind though.
nickramer
2021-11-15T15:27:56Z
Originally Posted by: RareSox 



To be honest, all they really need to do is just use the redub from the 2000s. They've shown the restored version during the opening scene to The Tom and Jerry show on MeTV. Although the redubbed soundtrack sounds more likely than what you said. I'll keep it in mind though.



Yeah, but a lot of people weren't too happy with the redubs if I recall.
RareSox
2021-11-17T17:17:22Z
If that's the case, either the original cut or none at all. I'll take either, besides the redraw.

And I'm not joking, it's only my opinion. Whatever makes MeTV happy. Although we could always ask MeTV to run a Tom and Jerry short featuring Two-Shoes in the Viewer's Choice.
2021-11-18T02:45:51Z
Does anyone know where i can find a good quality version of the 1960 cartoon “Horse Hare”. Digital or physical media would be fine. Please contact me at todays777@aol.com

nickramer
2021-11-26T18:53:24Z
Originally Posted by: RareSox 



We'll just have to see how The Little Orphan is treated tomorrow, although the blackface gag is likely a red flag that MeTV will likely cut. I'll be around to see it before I get a haircut tomorrow, so we'll just see how that rolls out.



Late replay, but "The Little Orphan" was shown last week and both scenes were edited (though, Two-Shoes was shown for a split second).
RareSox
2021-11-27T02:25:36Z
Why do I get the feeling that MeTV will start to resort to unrestored Turner dubs? I'm not even joking with this one. It's been happening a lot lately.
S. C. MacPeter
2021-11-27T23:48:06Z
Because that's what WB gave them, you have a very odd hate boner for them and I can't any say otherwise because you've made countless jokes about them in the past. Calm down
RareSox
2021-11-28T13:13:43Z
My apologies then. I guess this is the kind of package they had to work with. I can't really blame them for this.
RareSox
2021-11-29T13:06:35Z
Just got done posting today's episode in a server. In case you've missed it, the show was centered around money.

FOUR DOLLAR BILL
Today's shorts:

Heir-Conditioned (WB, 1955) Sylvester and Elmer Fudd
Daffy Dilly (WB, 1948) Daffy Duck
Robin Goodhood (DePatie-Freleng, 1970) Roland and Rattfink
Grin and Share It (MGM, 1957) Droopy
Honey's Money (WB, 1962) Yosemite Sam

Grin and Bear It is aired cropped, as per usual. Besides that, nothing really much of worth, unless you really like Daffy Dilly. But besides that, it's the usual schedule that you'd expect from Toon in with Me, with mentions of His Bitter Half and Hare Trimmed thrown in.