fulano7
  • fulano7
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2021-09-08T18:11:18Z
Make Mine Music and Melody Time blurays are available in the DMC store!!

https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=343098 

Screenshot:
https://imgur.com/a/nc0fqnK . There will be separate releases.

According to the purchase confirmation via email, the expected release date is Nov 2nd.
I always come to TTTP in Exile in the hope of finding news about Warner announcing Tex Avery Collection.
S. C. MacPeter
2021-09-08T18:57:22Z
I'll wait to see how Disney "fixes" the films' designs before considering a buy. Great news though as Make Mine Music is the only classic Disney animated film not on the +, but I forget what reason that would be
nickramer
2021-09-09T04:12:42Z
Before we jump up and down with joy on this, I would like to know if "Make Mine Music" will be complete with "The Martin and the Coys" sequences which was cut in the first video and DVD release as the studio was concern with the gun violence. This might also be the reason why it's not on Disney+ so far (which I find dumb as "The Simpsons" is on the service and that includes way more graphical gun violence on there).
Toonatic
2021-09-11T02:15:55Z
When both films wer eon Disney Family Movies on Demand they were uncut.

So it's possible that'll be the case here.

Incidentally, as someone pointed out in another forum, this means the Disney Animated Film Canon is complete on Blu-ray!!!
nickramer
2021-09-11T03:08:37Z
Originally Posted by: Toonatic 



Incidentally, as someone pointed out in another forum, this means the Disney Animated Film Canon is complete on Blu-ray!!!



I wish it was like that for Disney+ as well.
WaltWiz1901
2021-09-20T02:49:21Z
Haven't posted on here for some time (Discord's been my go-to place in regards to talking about classic animation with some of the members here for about a year), but I am pleased that both of these films are finally coming to Blu-ray! Would've preferred it if they were bundled together, but as Disney has kept the individual Gold Classic Collection DVDs in print for a long time, the way they're being sold makes a bit of sense.

Hoping that, with just about all of the (current) Disney Animated Canon titles out of the way, the DMC can issue classic shorts collections on BD next..
fulano7
  • fulano7
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2021-09-29T16:28:07Z
Originally Posted by: nickramer 

Before we jump up and down with joy on this, I would like to know if "Make Mine Music" will be complete with "The Martin and the Coys" sequences which was cut in the first video and DVD release as the studio was concern with the gun violence. This might also be the reason why it's not on Disney+ so far (which I find dumb as "The Simpsons" is on the service and that includes way more graphical gun violence on there).



To cut 7 minutes from the movie nowadays, in a DMC release, is a stretch. People have reported a running time shown in the purchase that indicates the first segment will be present.

When DMC released The Black Cauldron back in April, Class316 (from blu-ray.com forum) and I had the same feeling about Make Mine Music: that if it ever got a blu-ray release, it wouldn't have the brief sexual content on All The Cats Join In.

My bet is it will feature the guns, but not the boobs.
I always come to TTTP in Exile in the hope of finding news about Warner announcing Tex Avery Collection.
FoxInAFix
2021-09-30T05:18:54Z
Originally Posted by: fulano7 

Originally Posted by: nickramer 

Before we jump up and down with joy on this, I would like to know if "Make Mine Music" will be complete with "The Martin and the Coys" sequences which was cut in the first video and DVD release as the studio was concern with the gun violence. This might also be the reason why it's not on Disney+ so far (which I find dumb as "The Simpsons" is on the service and that includes way more graphical gun violence on there).



To cut 7 minutes from the movie nowadays, in a DMC release, is a stretch. People have reported a running time shown in the purchase that indicates the first segment will be present.

When DMC released The Black Cauldron back in April, Class316 (from blu-ray.com forum) and I had the same feeling about Make Mine Music: that if it ever got a blu-ray release, it wouldn't have the brief sexual content on All The Cats Join In.

My bet is it will feature the guns, but not the boobs.



Dare I say I saw a sneek peak, and it seems the boobs are indeed restored. The whole thing looks to be completely uncut.
S. C. MacPeter
2021-10-01T02:31:52Z
Fox, out of curiosity, if you can say, does the color quality and grain look good on that sneak peek?
Leviathan
2021-10-01T02:52:17Z
Originally Posted by: FoxInAFix 

Originally Posted by: fulano7 

Originally Posted by: nickramer 

Before we jump up and down with joy on this, I would like to know if "Make Mine Music" will be complete with "The Martin and the Coys" sequences which was cut in the first video and DVD release as the studio was concern with the gun violence. This might also be the reason why it's not on Disney+ so far (which I find dumb as "The Simpsons" is on the service and that includes way more graphical gun violence on there).



To cut 7 minutes from the movie nowadays, in a DMC release, is a stretch. People have reported a running time shown in the purchase that indicates the first segment will be present.

When DMC released The Black Cauldron back in April, Class316 (from blu-ray.com forum) and I had the same feeling about Make Mine Music: that if it ever got a blu-ray release, it wouldn't have the brief sexual content on All The Cats Join In.

My bet is it will feature the guns, but not the boobs.



Dare I say I saw a sneek peak, and it seems the boobs are indeed restored. The whole thing looks to be completely uncut.



That makes sense. It was completely uncut the last time Disney did anything with it (their Disney Family Movies on Demand service in 2015).

I take it the disc has some kind of "Guns are bad" PSA to account for Martins and the Coys.



WaltWiz1901
2021-10-07T18:46:07Z
More details about these two are out on the DMC website (member-only, unfortunately)...and going off what I've been hearing, like with The Black Cauldron, the shorts that were on the films' Gold Classic Collection DVDs are included:
- Make Mine Music comes with The Band Concert (previously released on Blu-ray on Celebrating Mickey), Music Land (the early 2000s master was originally released on BD as part of the Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and Beauty and the Beast Diamond Editions' "Hyperion Studios" and "Beyond Beauty" features), and Farmyard Symphony (new to BD)
- Melody Time comes with Donald Applecore, Lambert the Sheepish Lion, and Casey Bats Again...all of which are making their BD debuts (and the latter is making its debut on any format in restored form)
FoxInAFix
2021-10-14T06:03:51Z
Somehow it has leaked and has been shown to me some time ago. Like I said, the restoration that I saw was official and had no cuts or edits whatsoever.
fulano7
  • fulano7
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2021-10-14T17:17:51Z
Originally Posted by: FoxInAFix 

Somehow it has leaked and has been shown to me some time ago. Like I said, the restoration that I saw was official and had no cuts or edits whatsoever.



Isn't it the restoration Disney had put in Disney Family Movie On Demand? That restoration was ripped from TV and spread by Jack Sparrow in two releases: one with more compression artifacts and glitches and other glitchless and with better picture quality.
I always come to TTTP in Exile in the hope of finding news about Warner announcing Tex Avery Collection.
S. C. MacPeter
2021-10-16T04:01:08Z
Censored or not censored, can anyone provide a few screenshots of the HD master? I wanna make sure before I consider a buy if it LOOKS good
fulano7
  • fulano7
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2021-10-25T17:44:46Z
Originally Posted by: Mesterius 



Isn't that 720p version a DVD upscale or something? The lines look too soft for real HD.



That 720p version is a transcode (downscaled+deinterlaced+re-encoded) sourced from a 1080i TV recording.


I always come to TTTP in Exile in the hope of finding news about Warner announcing Tex Avery Collection.
Mesterius
2021-10-30T14:57:50Z
Originally Posted by: fulano7 

Originally Posted by: Mesterius 



Isn't that 720p version a DVD upscale or something? The lines look too soft for real HD.



That 720p version is a transcode (downscaled+deinterlaced+re-encoded) sourced from a 1080i TV recording.



Oh, really?? Do you know the source of the TV recording? I'm a little surprised there isn't a channel logo.
Toonatic
2021-11-01T00:20:50Z
I suggest we contact Disney and do something about this:

DMCcontactus@movieclubinfo.com
https://www.disneystudio...p.com/contact-bddvd.html 

I know in my heart we can make a difference so let's make something happen.
fulano7
  • fulano7
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2021-11-04T19:47:26Z
Originally Posted by: Mesterius 



Oh, really?? Do you know the source of the TV recording? I'm a little surprised there isn't a channel logo.



Really. I don't know what is the source of the TV recording (what channel, what country etc.).

I won't post direct links to fishy webpages. Nevertheless there are 2 master releases of uncensored Make Mine Music by Jack Sparrow that I know about.

1 - I came to find a first one because of screenshots posted on disneyplaza. Disneyplaza is a francophone Disney forum. So I searched for torrent releases with the French title of the film and found it on Torrent9. The torrent doesn't exist there anymore, only in YGG now. There is a 720p H264 and a 1080p H265 said to be HDTV, without logo, 720p and 1080p versions are the same recording, there is a glitch in the scene where the young couple is dancing in All The Cats Join In segment. Also, the picture is heavily compressed, with heavy and distracting macroblocking, even though the videos are both larger than 3 GB (3.19 GB and 3.82 GB). This release is credited to NASDAROV release group.

2 - The best one is credited to CtrlHD release group and was posted originally in 2015, but I only found it in 2020. It's a glitchless and logoless good 1080i recording. This release was used as source to the 720p H264 DON encode and the 1080p H265 MNHD-FRDS (a Chinese release group from KeepFriends "FRDS" Chinese tracker) encode. However I have neither the original 1080i CtrlHD release nor the 1080p MNHD release.

I don't know why neither of the HDTV recordings have logos. My guess is the recordings were taken from 16:9 broadcasts and the logo appeared originally within the unused vertical bars for 4:3 content.

In addition do HDTV, the movie was released uncensored through Disney Family Movies on demand. I also downloaded, from a dubbing enthusiasts online community, the very rare uncensored 1947 Brazilian dub, WEB-DLed from Telecine (a streaming platform) when the movie was available there, for a brief period in 2016, in 480p.
I always come to TTTP in Exile in the hope of finding news about Warner announcing Tex Avery Collection.